Published on:

California Hospital Worker Awarded $1 Million in Wrongful Termination Suit

When a worker suffers an on-the-job injury, what sort of accommodation is her employer legally required to make to ensure her ability to return to work? The law is deliberately vague on this subject, generally stating that employers must make “reasonable” accommodations. Failing to do so can lead to legal headaches.

Wrongful-TerminationThat’s the case for Dignity Health in California. Dignity manages St. John’s Pleasant Valley Hospital. Virginia Hoover had been working at the hospital for approximately 24 years as a radiologic technologist. In 2014, she suffered an injury to her shoulder while moving some equipment. The hospital granted her a leave of absence for recovery.

By August 2014, Hoover was cleared to return, but she was given limitations. She wasn’t supposed to lift anything heavier than 15 pounds with her non-dominant left arm and she was not permitted to raise that arm above her head. However, Hoover claims that Dignity made no effort to accommodate these restrictions. She was fired in December 2014 after her employer concluded that she couldn’t perform her duties.

Hoover filed a lawsuit against Dignity in 2016. Recently, a jury awarded her just over one million dollars for lost wages and emotional distress. The plaintiff claimed that Dignity had wrongfully terminated her and discriminated against her based on her age. Among the claims, Hoover says that another employee with similar restrictions had been accommodated by the hospital to remain in their position.

Dignity argued that they accommodated Hoover by granting her a leave of absence and then working with her to return to her duties. However, supervisors ultimately concluded that she wasn’t capable of performing the essential functions of her job.

In such cases, the law states that employers must find alternative work for an employee, but no documents from the lawsuit indicate whether or not this was attempted.

If you are an employer and one of your workers gets injured on the job, do you know how to comply with the relevant laws? Failing to do so can result in a costly lawsuit and negative publicity. If you are an California employer or business owner with questions about on the job injuries or any legal issue feel free to contact me, attorney Richard Oppenheim at 818-461-8500 or via the Contact form on this page.