Published on:

Disney Suffers Setback in Redbox Lawsuit

The Walt Disney Company recently suffered a setback in a California federal court. Specifically, a judge has denied Disney’s request for a preliminary injunction against Redbox that would have forced the DVD-rental company to stop reselling the download codes for digital copies of the studio’s films.

redbox-1Redbox’s movie rental kiosks have become a familiar part of the landscape in recent years. Consumers stop by these kiosks for the latest releases. For the most part, Redbox has distribution deals with the major movie studios that allow them to profit by renting out the studios’ films. However, Redbox has no such agreement with Disney.

Accordingly, Redbox purchases Disney-distributed movies from retailers, then slips them into their kiosks for customer rental. Disney and other movie studios frequently put new films in combo packs that feature DVD and Blu-ray copies of the films along with a download code for getting a digital copy. In addition to renting DVDs and Blu-rays, Redbox has been selling the download codes on slips of paper that are obtainable at their kiosks.

When Disney found out about this practice, they immediately launched a lawsuit. Among the charges in the complaint were copyright infringement, false advertising, unfair competition, tortious interference with customer contracts and breach of contract. Redbox quickly countersued, arguing that the studio was trying to stifle possible competition for its soon-to-be launched digital streaming service.

Not only has a federal judge denied Disney’s request that Redbox be stopped from re-selling download codes, but also the judge says Disney is actually misusing copyright law. On each Disney movie combo pack, consumers will find language stating that the download code cannot be sold or transferred. The studio argued that this constitutes a legally binding contract, but the judge did not agree. In fact, the judge said that there is no law that prevents what Redbox did. After the “first sale,” which was the lawful purchase of the combo pack, the owner is then free to dispose of the copies as they wish.

Copyright law can be incredibly nuanced. Work with a skilled business attorney to protect your intellectual property rights.